Onion family

Onion Companion Planting: What to Grow With Onions and What to Avoid

By the editorial team · Updated 2026-11-19 · Every pairing linked to its source

Quick answer. The best onion companion plants are carrots, broccoli and cabbage. Young onions among carrots reduced carrot fly and onion thrips in a UK trial, and onion rows cut caterpillar damage on broccoli and cabbage in Iowa. Beets, lettuce and tomatoes are traditional partners. Keep onions away from beans, peas, asparagus and sage.

Botanical illustration of onion
Spacing
3-4 in · 8-10 cm
Season
Cool season
Sun
Full
Rotate with
Amaryllidaceae (onion family, formerly Alliaceae)

Onions are a cool-season, full-sun crop grown close together: 3–4 in (8–10 cm) apart, in rows 12–24 in (30–60 cm) wide, with sets planted 1.5–2 in deep. Their upright, narrow leaves cast almost no shade, so onions slip easily into rows beside other vegetables.

That makes onions more often the helper than the helped. In two separate trials, onions protected their neighbors: carrots from carrot fly and brassicas from caterpillars. The flip side is a long-standing chart warning that onions stunt beans and peas.

Onion companion chart

Good companions

PlantWhyEvidence
BroccoliIn a field study, onions cut caterpillar damage on neighboring broccoli.Provensource
CabbageIn a field study, onions planted among cabbage reduced cabbageworm and looper damage.Provensource
CarrotIn a field trial, onion rows among carrots reduced carrot fly and onion thrips.Provensource
BeetBeets are one of the most common onion companions; no trial yet.Traditionalsource
CauliflowerA traditional pairing; no trial with cauliflower so far.Traditionalsource
CeleryCelery is a traditional onion partner; untested — try it and see.Traditionalsource
KaleA traditional pairing; onion trials covered broccoli and cabbage, not kale.Traditionalsource
LettuceLettuce is a classic onion companion; no trial yet, but both stay compact.Traditionalsource
PepperPeppers are a traditional onion companion; no trial evidence.Traditionalsource
PotatoPotatoes are an old onion companion; no trial yet.Traditionalsource
RhubarbUK gardeners plant onions by rhubarb to deter aphids and weevils; unverified.Traditionalsource
SpinachSpinach is a traditional onion partner; no trial yet.Traditionalsource
StrawberryStrawberries are a traditional onion companion; untested, but onions take little room.Traditionalsource
Swiss chardChard is an old onion companion; no trial evidence.Traditionalsource
TomatoTomatoes are a classic onion partner; no trial yet — try it and see.Traditionalsource
DillDill is traditionally said to help onions; untested.Traditionalsource
LavenderLavender is traditionally said to help onions; no trial yet.Traditionalsource

Keep apart

PlantWhyEvidence
AsparagusTradition keeps asparagus away from onions; no reason has been documented.Traditionalsource
Beans (bush & pole)Onions are said to stunt beans; an old warning that hasn't been tested.Traditionalsource
PeasOnions are said to stunt peas; a traditional warning without a trial.Traditionalsource
SageTradition calls sage a poor onion neighbor; no reason is known.Traditionalsource

Proven Backed by a field trial or published study. Practical Recommended by a university extension or the RHS, with a clear reason. Traditional Gardener lore; no trial found yet.

What to Plant With Onions

Proven pairings

  • Carrot — Proven. In a UK field trial, onion rows among carrots reduced carrot fly, and mixing the two also cut onion thrips. The carrot fly effect holds only while the onions are young and leafy.
  • Broccoli — Proven. Onions reduced looper and cabbageworm damage on neighboring broccoli in an Iowa trial.
  • Cabbage — Proven. The same Iowa study recorded less cabbageworm and looper damage on cabbage interplanted with onions.

Traditional pairings

  • Beet — one of the few pairings that UC Davis, UF and NDSU all agree on.
  • Lettuce — listed by UC Davis, UF and NDSU. Lettuce grows low between the upright onion leaves.
  • Tomato and pepper — listed by NDSU, UC or UF.
  • Cauliflower and kale — listed through UC Davis's cabbage-family entry; the caterpillar trial didn't include them.
  • Celery, spinach, Swiss chard, potato and strawberry — on the UF or NDSU charts.
  • Rhubarb — UK garden guides pair them, claiming aphid and weevil deterrence; unverified.
  • Dill and lavender — an Oregon State sheet lists both as enhancing onion and garlic.

What Not to Plant With Onions

  • Beans — Traditional. UC Davis and NDSU say onions stunt beans.
  • Peas — Traditional. UC Davis, UF and NDSU all say onions stunt peas.
  • Asparagus — Traditional. The UF/IFAS chart lists it as a bad onion companion, without a mechanism.
  • Sage — Traditional. Also listed as bad by UF/IFAS, again without a mechanism.

The bean and pea warning deserves a note. The charts are unusually consistent about it, but no trial evidence was found. Keeping them in separate beds costs nothing, so it's an easy rule to follow while the question stays open.

Onions and Carrots: Timing Is Everything

The onion–carrot pairing is the classic example of companion planting, and the research gives it a twist. In the Uvah and Coaker trial, onions cut carrot fly attack only while they were young; once the onions began to bulb, the effect disappeared. The same trial found a French marigold intercrop did nothing against carrot fly.

To make the pairing work:

  • Sow carrots and onions at the same time, in alternating rows.
  • Use plenty of onions, so their leafy stage overlaps the carrots' most vulnerable weeks.
  • Expect less protection in mid to late summer, after the onions bulb.

Onions Beside Broccoli and Cabbage

Onions take little space, so they tuck into the gaps between young brassicas. In the Iowa study, onions reduced looper and cabbageworm damage on both broccoli and cabbage. Plant a row between the brassica rows, or a ring of onion sets around each young plant, and harvest the onions as green onions or let them bulb.

Pages from the printable companion planting chart PDF

Free printable PDF

Get the complete companion planting chart

Print the onion card and the pest-to-protector table to see exactly which crops onions protect and which ones they're said to stunt.

  • 1-page fridge chart + full 50 × 50 matrix
  • 50 plant cards with spacing and reasons
  • 6 bed plans drawn to scale
  • US Letter and A4

Spacing Onions Among Other Crops

Onions are planted close: 3–4 in (8–10 cm) apart, with sets 1.5–2 in deep and rows 12–24 in (30–60 cm) wide. That tight spacing and their upright leaves let them slot into places other crops can't use, such as alternate rows in a carrot bed or the gaps between young broccoli. Lettuce and beets also grow well in the rows beside them. Keep a full bed's width between onions and any beans or peas.

Does It Really Work?

Yes, in specific ways. Onions have real trial results with carrots and with broccoli and cabbage. The carrot fly effect is time-limited. The "keep away" list is tradition—consistent across charts, but untested—so treat it as a sensible default rather than a proven rule.

Frequently asked questions

What cannot be planted near onions?

Charts from UC Davis, UF and NDSU consistently list beans and peas as onion enemies, saying onions stunt them, though no trial has confirmed it. The UF/IFAS chart also lists asparagus and sage as bad onion companions. Since these are easy to keep apart, it's a low-cost rule to follow.

What is the best companion plant for onions?

Carrots are the best-known partner. A UK field trial found young onion rows reduced carrot fly on carrots and that mixing the two cut onion thrips. Onions also reduced caterpillar damage on broccoli and cabbage in an Iowa study. Beets and lettuce are traditional partners on every major chart.

Can onions be planted in the same place every year?

It's better not to. Onions belong to the onion family with garlic and chives, and rotating that family to a new bed each year is standard practice. Follow onions with a crop from a different family, and remember that beans and peas are poor neighbors for onions, according to the charts.

Do onions keep carrot fly away?

Partly, and only for a while. In the Uvah and Coaker trial, intercropped onions cut carrot fly attack while they were young and leafy, but the effect vanished once the onions started to bulb. Sow carrots and onions together and use plenty of onions to cover the carrots' early weeks.

More vegetables

All vegetables →